Bidspirit auction | SFAS EMES. Autograph Halakhic Responsum


SFAS EMES. Autograph Halakhic Responsum Concerning the Release of an Agunah - R. Yehudah Aryeh Leib Alter of Gur (1847–1905), author of Sefas Emes Autograph halakhic responsum, entirely in the hand of the Sefas Emes , opening with the words ”בהיתר אשה זו.” The responsum addresses one of the most sensitive and consequential areas of Jewish law: the permissibility of allowing an agunah to remarry. The case concerns a man who disappeared while traveling and was presumed drowned. After a body was recovered from the water and identified by those who knew him, the Sefas Emes undertakes a careful analysis of the two principal evidentiary issues upon which the woman's status depended: whether sufficient time had elapsed for decomposition to render ordinary facial identification unreliable, and whether the witnesses' טביעות עין (recognition based upon distinctive identifying characteristics) was sufficiently precise to establish the deceased's identity according to halakhah. Weighing the opinions of the earlier authorities, the responsum exemplifies the exceptional caution exercised by halakhic decisors in cases where a single ruling would determine whether a woman could remarry. The manuscript is especially noteworthy in light of the Sefas Emes' surviving literary legacy. Unlike many of the leading halakhic authorities of his generation, relatively few responsa of the Sefas Emes have survived, and he is not generally associated with the extensive literature of heter agunah. According to a tradition preserved by his grandson, R. Pinchas Menachem Alter (the Pnei Menachem), this very case had initially been presented to another eminent rabbinic authority, who indicated that he would permit the woman to remarry only if three additional rabbis concurred in his ruling, one of whom was to be the Sefas Emes. The present manuscript thus preserves the Gur Rebbe's independent halakhic analysis in a matter for which his judgment was specifically sought as one of the decisive voices. One and one-half pages, with an additional half-page continuation. Unsigned, as frequently encountered in working manuscripts and responsa transmitted directly to the inquirer. The authenticity of the handwriting and identification has been confirmed by Harav Shmerel Zitronenbaum, well-known expert and maven on antique rabbinic manuscripts and handwritten Torah novellae. Reference: Zikhron Arba (Jerusalem, 1988), pp. 28ff. Opening price: $44,000