Bidspirit auction | UNPUBLISHED ARCHIVE OF LETTERS OF
UNPUBLISHED ARCHIVE OF LETTERS OF THE DEVAR AVRAHAM, RAV AVRAHAM DOVBER KAHANE - REVOLUTIONALLY INSIGHT INTO HIS MEDICAL RESEARCH - Much thanks to Rabbi Elisha Friedman for his extensive research on this archive and Ovadya Hoffman for his cataloging and expanded research 9 Autograph letters of the Devar Avraham and additional letters From Dr Levy and additional letters from German Doctors An extraordinary archive documenting the research, development, and dissemination of Rabbi Avraham Dovber Kahane-Shapiro’s remarkable scientific defense of the laws of Taharat HaMishpachah (niddah) , and revealing with unusual clarity the intellectual world of one of twentieth-century Europe’s foremost rabbinic authorities. R. Avraham Dovber Kahane-Shapiro (1870–1943), author of the celebrated three-volume Dvar Avraham and, from 1913 until his death, the last chief rabbi of Kovno, was one of the towering Torah scholars and communal leaders of prewar Lithuanian Jewry. A graduate of the Volozhin yeshiva and scion of a distinguished rabbinic family, he was renowned primarily for his profound analytical Talmudic scholarship and his leadership of Kovno, one of the great intellectual centers of European Jewish life. Yet these previously unpublished letters to the German Orthodox physician Dr. Jacob Levy reveal another dimension of his intellectual personality: an extraordinary and sustained private engagement with modern science. The correspondence, consisting of nine letters from Rabbi Kahane-Shapiro to Dr. Levy, together with surviving letters and notes from Levy, spans April 1937 through August 1938. It follows the research and publication process surrounding Rabbi Kahane-Shapiro’s unusual work on Taharat HaMishpachah, a project in which he sought to encourage observance of the laws of niddah by demonstrating, among other things, their compatibility with—and possible basis in—contemporary medical and scientific knowledge. The project originated in a public address Rabbi Kahane-Shapiro delivered before thousands of women in Kovno on the second day of Chanukah 1936, organized by the Beth Yaakov organization to promote observance of Taharat HaMishpachah. Inspired in part by a similar address delivered by the Chafetz Chaim in Vilna in 1931, the 66-year-old Kovno rabbi overcame his own discomfort at speaking publicly to women about an intimate subject because he regarded the effort as an important rabbinic responsibility. The speech was subsequently expanded into a 124-page Yiddish booklet, Speech on Taharat HaMishpachah, published in Kedainiai in 1938. A Hebrew translation, with additional material, followed in 1940. The booklet is striking not merely because a leading Lithuanian rabbi attempted to explain a mitzvah through contemporary science, but because of the astonishing breadth of the scientific literature he marshaled. Kahane-Shapiro cited physicians, gynecologists, biologists, chemists, pharmacologists, psychologists, sociologists, and philosophers, drawing upon books, journals, newspapers, and essays published in English, German, Hebrew, and French. Among the figures he consulted or cited were Dr. Bela Schick of Vienna; Dr. David Macht of Baltimore; gynecologists Otto Küstner, Hiram Vineberg, and Gaston Cotte; Felix Theilhaber; Yaakov Smithline; Marie Stopes; Sigmund Freud; F. C. S. Schiller; and Henri Bergson. At the center of his argument was the then-current scientific theory of menotoxins—the belief that menstrual secretions contained toxic substances capable of producing physiological effects. The theory had received considerable attention in the scientific world during the 1920s and 1930s, following the experiments of the Viennese Jewish pediatrician Dr. Bela Schick. Kahane-Shapiro incorporated this contemporary theory into a much older Jewish tradition of seeking rational explanations for the laws of niddah, including the famous discussion of menstrual impurity in the writings of Ramban, himself a physician. Kahane-Shapiro’s argument went beyond menotoxins. He cited contemporary research concerning gynecology, menstrual physiology, fertility, uterine cancer, bacteriology, pharmacology, chromosomes, and other aspects of human biology. He argued, among other things, that Jewish women appeared to have lower rates of uterine cancer and explored whether this could be connected to the observance of niddah. At the same time, he repeatedly insisted that these explanations were secondary: the laws of Torah are observed because they are commanded by God, regardless of whether their reasons can be scientifically demonstrated. It is precisely here that the correspondence with Dr. Jacob Levy becomes extraordinary. The letters provide a rare documentary record of the research process behind the published work, transforming what might otherwise appear to be an unusually learned rabbinic pamphlet into the visible product of a sustained research enterprise. The first letter, dated 9 Iyar 5697 (April 5, 1937),