Bidspirit auction | Autograph Teshuvah by Rabbi Moshe
Autograph Teshuvah by Rabbi Moshe Feinstein to Rabbi Tuvia Goldstein. Seven Manuscript Leaves. The Autograph Draft of Igros Moshe, Yoreh De'ah I, no. 224. - Few halachic authorities have shaped the landscape of twentieth-century Jewish law as profoundly as Rabbi Moshe Feinstein (1895-1986). To countless readers, the Igros Moshe presents a finished corpus: lucid, precise responsa whose conclusions appear with remarkable confidence and clarity. Manuscripts such as the present one reveal the creative process behind those volumes, allowing the reader to witness one of the century's greatest halachic minds at work. This substantial autograph responsum, extending across seven closely written leaves and signed by Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, was addressed to his close friend and esteemed colleague Rabbi Tuvia Goldstein (1917-2003), one of the outstanding rabbinic scholars of postwar America. Their relationship extended far beyond ordinary correspondence. For many years the two lived in the same Lower East Side building, consulted one another regularly on difficult halachic questions, and maintained a warm intellectual friendship grounded in mutual respect. Rabbi Tuvia's exceptional mastery of rabbinic literature made him one of the select scholars with whom Rabbi Moshe discussed complex halachic issues before publication, and Igros Moshe itself occasionally preserves traditions transmitted in his name. The responsum itself offers an equally fascinating glimpse into Rabbi Moshe's method of composition. Across seven pages of sustained Talmudic analysis, the argument unfolds with extraordinary fluency. Only a handful of corrections interrupt the manuscript , leaving before the reader the rare spectacle of an intricate halachic discussion taking shape almost continuously upon the page. The ease with which the argument progresses gives tangible expression to the intellectual clarity for which Rabbi Moshe became renowned. An especially revealing feature is the manuscript's place within the evolution of Igros Moshe. Rabbi Moshe himself numbered this responsum Siman 203, yet when the first volume of Yoreh De'ah eventually appeared in print, it was published as Siman 224. The manuscript thus preserves an earlier stage in the organization of the collection, before the final arrangement of the volume had been settled. Some even observed, R. Moshe would often have copied and edited responsa three times. It stands as a witness to the editorial process through which one of the most influential halachic works of the modern era assumed its published form. Equally striking is the physical manuscript itself. Every page was written not on the face of Rabbi Moshe's official Mesivtha Tifereth Jerusalem stationery, but on its blank reverse. Whether chosen from economy, convenience, or simply the informality permitted between close friends, the result is deeply evocative. The institutional letterhead remains hidden on the verso, while every visible surface is devoted entirely to Torah, giving the manuscript the intimate character of a working draft prepared for a trusted colleague rather than a formal presentation copy. This manuscript is the autograph source for the responsum later published as Igros Moshe , Yoreh De'ah I, no. 224. Reference : Finkelman, Reb Moshe: The Life and Ideals of HaGaon Rabbi Moshe Feinstein; Deutsch, Ish Halachah: Toldot Hayav shel Rabbi Tuvia Goldstein; Gordin, Rav Moshe Feinstein (Alon Shvut 2017) 16ff. Provenance: The collection of R. Shmuel Dovid Friedman, the Sede Tzofim Opening price: $4,000